LED lighting retrofits: how to estimate payback

Payback equals net project cost divided by annual savings. Get the savings right by counting fixtures, measuring real operating hours and using your own blended electric rate.

By the San Diego Green Chamber · Updated November 2026

Electrician installing LED fixtures in a warehouse ceiling

To estimate LED retrofit payback, divide the net project cost by the annual savings. Annual savings come from the wattage you remove, multiplied by the hours the lights run and your electric rate, plus maintenance and any cooling savings. Most of the error in payback estimates comes from guessing hours or using the wrong rate, so measure both before you trust a contractor’s number.

The basic payback formula

Simple payback, in years, is:

Payback = (project cost minus incentives) / annual savings

And annual energy savings, in kWh, are:

kWh saved = (old watts minus new watts) x number of fixtures x annual operating hours / 1,000

Multiply kWh saved by your blended electric rate to get annual dollar savings. Add maintenance savings, then divide the net cost by the total.

Gather the right inputs

  1. Count fixtures by type. Walk every space and list each fixture type, how many lamps it holds and the ballast. Do not rely on old drawings.
  2. Find real wattage. Use the fixture’s actual input watts, including the ballast, not just the lamp rating. Fluorescent ballasts add load that is easy to miss.
  3. Measure operating hours. Note when each area’s lights are actually on. A warehouse aisle, a restroom and a sales floor can run very different hours. Inexpensive light loggers help if you are unsure.
  4. Use your blended rate. Divide your total electric charges by total kWh over 12 months of SDG&E bills for a realistic average. On time-of-use plans, lights that run during the 4 p.m. to 9 p.m. peak save more per kWh.
  5. Get the installed cost. Ask for a quote that includes labor, disposal, lift rental and any controls.

A worked example

Here is how the math works, using round hypothetical numbers. Plug in your own figures, because rates and costs vary.

A warehouse has 100 fluorescent fixtures drawing 64 watts each, replaced with LED fixtures drawing 30 watts. The lights run 3,000 hours a year. The wattage reduction is 34 watts per fixture. Savings are 34 x 100 x 3,000 / 1,000 = 10,200 kWh per year. Multiply that by your blended rate from your bill to get annual dollars saved. Divide the net project cost by that figure for simple payback in years.

Notice what drives the result. Double the operating hours and the savings double. Use a rate that is too high and payback looks shorter than it will be. That is why the inputs matter more than the formula. A fixture schedule with measured hours is worth an afternoon of work before you sign anything.

If the same retrofit adds occupancy sensors that cut operating hours by a quarter in low-traffic aisles, recalculate with the lower hours for those fixtures. Controls often change the answer more than the fixture choice does.

Savings people forget, and costs they miss

Extra savings

  • Maintenance. LEDs last far longer than fluorescent tubes, so you buy and replace lamps less often. Count the labor, especially where a lift is needed.
  • Cooling. LEDs give off less heat, which slightly reduces air conditioning load in cooled spaces. Inland buildings with long cooling seasons benefit most.
  • Demand charges. If your rate has them, lower lighting load can reduce your monthly peak.

Costs to include

  • Disposal. Fluorescent lamps contain mercury and are universal waste in California. They cannot go in the trash and must be recycled through a proper handler.
  • Code requirements. Larger lighting alterations can trigger Title 24 lighting control requirements, such as occupancy sensing or daylight controls. Your contractor should check.
  • Product type. Plug-and-play LED tubes are cheapest up front but still depend on the old ballast. Ballast-bypass tubes and new fixtures cost more but remove that failure point.

Check the incentives and the quote

Ask SDG&E and your contractor about current business lighting incentives before you sign, since programs change and some require approval before installation. Some programs also set product requirements, such as listings from the DesignLights Consortium, so confirm eligibility before you choose fixtures. When you compare quotes, make sure each one lists fixture counts, input watts before and after, assumed hours and the rate used. If a quote’s hours or rate look high, the payback will look better than it is.

Simple payback also ignores the life of the project. LED fixtures can keep saving for many years after they have paid for themselves, so a three or four year payback on a fixture that lasts much longer is a strong return. If you need to make the case to a lender or partner, ask your contractor for lifetime savings as well as payback.

If lighting is one of several projects you are weighing, a commercial energy audit can rank it against HVAC and controls upgrades. Lighting and controls contractors in our energy efficiency and HVAC network can provide quotes with the detail you need.

How chamber membership helps

An LED retrofit is one of the clearest, most measurable steps toward the commitment every San Diego Green Chamber member makes to reduce energy and water use. Members find contractors through the Member Business Directory, get education on programs and code changes, and meet peers at free networking events co-hosted with San Diego Green Drinks. Before-and-after bills from a retrofit also make strong evidence for the chamber’s sustainability certification options. Learn about membership.

Questions

What is a typical payback for an LED retrofit?

It depends on your hours, rate, existing fixtures and project cost. Buildings with long operating hours and old fluorescent or metal halide fixtures usually pay back fastest. Run the formula with your own numbers.

Can I throw old fluorescent tubes in the trash?

No. In California, fluorescent lamps are universal waste because they contain mercury. Recycle them through a hauler, retailer program or facility that accepts them.

Do LED retrofits trigger Title 24 requirements?

Larger lighting alterations can trigger Title 24 lighting control requirements. Ask your contractor to confirm what applies before finalizing the scope.

Prove it. Get referred for it.

Join the San Diego Green Chamber to get listed, introduced and referred by businesses that check.

Join the Chamber Find a Business