Sustainable packaging for a small brand means using less material, choosing formats that are widely recycled or composted where your customers live, and making only claims you can back up. In California, that also means planning for SB 54, the state’s packaging producer responsibility law, and following the state’s rules on recyclable and compostable labels. Start with an audit of what you ship today and cut before you switch.
Start with a packaging audit
List every piece of packaging that leaves your business: primary packaging around the product, secondary packaging such as boxes and sleeves, shipping materials, inserts, tape and labels. For each piece, note the material, weight, supplier, cost per unit and why it exists. You will usually find items that do nothing useful, such as a box inside a box or an insert nobody reads.
This audit pays off twice. It shows you where to cut, and it gives you the data you will need if your business falls under SB 54 reporting. Keep the spreadsheet current as you change suppliers.
Reduce first, then switch materials
The cheapest and most defensible packaging is the packaging you don’t use. Right-size boxes so you need less void fill. Drop unnecessary layers. Print instructions on the box instead of an insert. Use concentrated formulas or refills where the product allows. Each of these cuts material cost and shipping weight, which customers notice.
For online sellers, shipping materials are often the largest share by volume. Paper mailers, recycled-content corrugated boxes, paper tape and paper void fill keep the whole package in the paper recycling stream. Plastic air pillows and bubble mailers are much harder for customers to recycle at the curb. Print short disposal instructions on the box itself so customers know where each part goes.
When you do need packaging, choose materials that local recycling systems actually accept. In San Diego County curbside programs, the most reliable materials are:
- Corrugated cardboard and paperboard without plastic coatings.
- Clear PET (#1) and HDPE (#2) plastic bottles and jugs.
- Glass bottles and jars.
- Aluminum and steel cans.
Avoid formats that look green but rarely get recycled: multi-layer laminated pouches, black plastic that sorting machines struggle to detect, small items that fall through sorting screens, and mixed materials that can’t be separated, such as paper bonded to plastic film. Check with your local hauler or your city’s environmental services department for what is accepted.
Compostable and bio-based packaging
Compostable packaging only helps if it ends up in a facility that accepts it. Many commercial composting operations in California don’t take compostable plastics, and home compost piles rarely break them down. California’s AB 1201 sets rules for products labeled compostable, including certification and labeling requirements. Use compostable packaging where it has a clear route, such as food-contact items collected with food scraps, and confirm acceptance locally first.
Bio-based plastics are made from plants rather than fossil fuels, but bio-based does not mean compostable or recyclable. Be precise about which property you are claiming.
What SB 54 and SB 343 mean for you
SB 54, the Plastic Pollution Prevention and Packaging Producer Responsibility Act, makes producers responsible for the single-use packaging and plastic foodware they sell into California. It sets goals for source reduction, recycling rates and making covered packaging recyclable or compostable by 2032. Producers must join a producer responsibility organization and report on their packaging. Very small producers below a sales threshold may be exempt. CalRecycle’s revised implementing regulations took effect in May 2026, so check current requirements and deadlines directly with CalRecycle.
SB 343 limits when you can use the chasing arrows symbol or call a product recyclable. The material must meet statewide criteria for collection and sorting, based on CalRecycle data. If your packaging doesn’t meet them, remove the symbol and the claim. This is a common trap for small brands that order stock packaging printed with recycling symbols.
Questions to ask packaging suppliers
- What is the material, and is it a single material or a combination?
- What percentage is post-consumer recycled content, and can you document it?
- Is it accepted in San Diego County curbside recycling or organics collection?
- If it is labeled compostable, what certification does it carry?
- Does the printed artwork include recycling symbols, and do they meet California rules?
- Can you provide documentation I can use for SB 54 reporting?
Ask for samples and test them in real shipping. Packaging that fails in transit creates more waste than it saves. Expect some cost trade-offs, too. Recycled-content and specialty materials can cost more per unit, but cutting material and shipping weight often offsets the difference, and small brands can pool orders with other local makers to reach supplier minimums. Then talk about your packaging honestly in marketing. Our guide to marketing eco products without greenwashing explains how to describe these changes without overclaiming. Other makers in our sustainable products and retail network are dealing with the same suppliers and rules.
How chamber membership helps
The San Diego Green Chamber brings together businesses that have committed to reducing energy and water use and want their sustainability to hold up to scrutiny. Members get education and resources, advocacy through a unified voice on policy, a Member Business Directory listing and free networking co-hosted with San Diego Green Drinks, where you can compare notes with other brands. Learn about membership.
Questions
What is the most sustainable packaging for a small brand?
Usually the packaging you eliminate. After that, choose single-material formats that are widely recycled locally, such as cardboard, glass, aluminum and #1 or #2 plastic bottles.
Does SB 54 apply to small businesses?
SB 54 applies to producers of covered packaging sold in California, with an exemption for very small producers below a sales threshold. Confirm your status and current rules with CalRecycle.
Can I put the recycling symbol on my packaging?
Only if the material meets California’s statewide recyclability criteria under SB 343. Otherwise, remove the chasing arrows and any recyclable claim.
Is compostable packaging better than recyclable packaging?
Only when it reaches a facility that accepts it. Many California composters don’t accept compostable plastics, so check local acceptance first.
Prove it. Get referred for it.
Join the San Diego Green Chamber to get listed, introduced and referred by businesses that check.
